The Green Book Jill Paton Walsh Read Free

See a Problem?
Thank you for telling us about the problem.
Friend Reviews
Customs Reviews


Actually, I want more of it. I want more time on the spaceship, I want more near the new village on Shine, I desire more than about their new lives, and I want more almost the books they brought, the ones they left behind and half-remember, and the new ones they write.
...more
The book takes place at an unspecified date in the future when the sun is dying for an unspecified reason. The main characters--similar many people on the planet--are leaving the earth--however, the nation that they vest to is poor, and cannot afford to take much with them. They can therefore only take a few crops and animals with them, and each person tin I vividly remember reading this book in the fifth grade. I establish it unscientific, wildly implausible, vague, and artistically undistinguished.
The book takes place at an unspecified date in the future when the sunday is dying for an unspecified reason. The chief characters--similar many people on the planet--are leaving the earth--however, the nation that they belong to is poor, and cannot afford to have much with them. They can therefore only have a few crops and animals with them, and each person can merely take a single book. The principal grapheme-- a young daughter--chooses to take a green notebook with her, in which she records the events that take place on the new earth. This, even so, does non alibi the book's numerous scientific flaws, which for me made the volume a laughable read.
*Stars, when they die, practice not shrink and turn bluish as the book depicts--they instead plough red, and even a sun-sized star would abound in size.
*Though the ship has a estimator that is advanced enough to play games with the passengers, it never occurs to the designers to identify a library of books in the calculator. Additionally, it seems that the author never predictable the cheapness of computing applied science which would eventually arise.
*An interstellar journey would never take four years unless i had been using some currently unknown method of superluminal travel. The book makes no mention of this.
*The planet is too Earthlike--i cannot expect that at that place would be anything resembling a tree, a blade of grass, or other characteristic of terrestrial biology on that planet.
*Life cannot get crystalline either from living in a soil or from a diet. This is but, utterly absurd--such a thing is effectively equivalent to completely restructuting the elementary composition and molecular processes of an organism without killing it--and the simplest fashion by which one could legitimately explicate this concept in a serious work would require the use of extremely advanced nanotechnology.
The scientific errors are potentially ignorable, but, as I am very knowledgeable as to science, I found that these books--every bit well every bit the poor presentation of the story by my fifth grade teachers--were non at all of any interest to me.* The writing style is simply barely distinguished with respect to other authors, and information technology is funny that a child would even be able to utilise the word "treacle", as the main graphic symbol does in the outset chapter.
*Footnote: I have a grudge against the school, in role for how they taught this volume. For instance, when we as a class arrived at the scene where the children discover a sweetness substance, the whole form did a science essay on sugar, never once mentioning that not all sweet substances are sugars. It was only a 5th-course class, of course--simply I was highly annoyed even then, especially when a kid told me that "saccharide was fabricated of carbon dioxide"--a decision made from our experiments with using yeast to measure sugar. I could go on to discuss the other crap they taught us, just I will hash out that in a different review.
...more


And it actually bewitched me that the illustrator hadn't read carefully. All the roof shingles in his illustrations were SQUARE. And the moths were entirely fairy-like, every bit opposed to the descriptions in the text.
I say information technology's spinach.
...more
It's kind of fun to read old sci-fi's envisioning of the 21st century (and across). I exercise find it funny that in the pre-Internet era, so many authors had trouble conceiving of computers as little more than clunky, tape-eating data-logging machines--fifty-fifty far into the time to come. Also, those fuel-burning Earth machines could accept benef
It seems that this little volume has attracted a lot of heated opinions, which is odd. It's not a classic of junior sci-fi literature by any stretch, but information technology's not that bad.It's kind of fun to read old sci-fi'southward envisioning of the 21st century (and beyond). I do find information technology funny that in the pre-Internet era, so many authors had trouble conceiving of computers every bit little more than clunky, record-eating data-logging machines--even far into the hereafter. As well, those fuel-called-for Earth machines could take benefited from solar cell technology. Finally, carrying live chickens and rabbits on a spaceship to a new planet many calorie-free-years from dwelling is ridiculously inefficient--even small farmed animals consume precious nutrient and water supplies, and their consumption isn't necessary for human survival.
...more
and our mother chimed in, "even so, you're still reading information technology!" all i kept thinking when i was reading this to my sister was, "what a bad book."
and our mother chimed in, "still, you're yet reading it!" ...more than



Or 1.eight stars if yous are an developed who nitpicks science and logic in books for 10-year olds.
Also consider these similar juvenile/YA SF books:
The Keeper of the Isis Calorie-free
Enchantress from The Stars
Or 1.8 stars if you are an adult who nitpicks science and logic in books for x-year olds.
Also consider these similar juvenile/YA SF books:
The Keeper of the Isis Light
Enchantress from The Stars

The trip takes several years, in which time the main character Pattie, grows from a small child into an inquisitive girl. Upon arriving, there is a moment earlier the passengers will notice out if the planet is livable, whether at that place is water, if their seeds will grow, and are at that place any potential dangers. Similar every moment in this novel, it handled excellently. Volition a careful use of words, Jill Paton Walsh is able to capture all the tension without e'er embellishing or resorting to melodrama.
Life on this new planet is seen through Pattie'southward eyes, and and then while the difficulties are visible, what the reader truly feels is the sense of discovery that the foreign world exhibits. Information technology is the gift of a child to see joy fifty-fifty in the midst of struggle.
A surprise twist at the end but works to strengthen this book and make information technology even more endearing than it already had been.
...more than
The moth creatures were amazing and the scene where they are playing with the children is cute.
Lack of communication between the group, both earlier departing Earth and during their troubles, causes all sorts of problems, including multiple copies of the same book in a library I loved the concept and the descriptive writing is, every bit always from JPW, wonderfully evocative. I wanted it to exist longer and a little less unproblematic, although, as it is written from a child's point of view, it is equally it is.
Lack of communication between the grouping, both before parting Earth and during their troubles, causes all sorts of problems, including multiple copies of the aforementioned book in a library of few. ...more


I would be more than
A short and sweet children'south sci-fi story. At that place's certainly scientific inaccuracies simply from a child'southward eyes, even if they notice them, they will probable be able to suspend disbelief for the story and the imagery. The translucent wood from the trees forming huts full of shadowy grey calorie-free in the day, and at night allowing them to glow the warm flickering crimson of the fire and points of green from the jellyfish oil lamps, making the houses look similar bits of burn down opal is a lovely idea!I would be more concerned that it's sci-fi that reflects the engineering science of the time it was written, and that could confuse younger readers. They mention using tapes in the reckoner and its talks of playing Monopoly or Mastermind against a computer, and information technology being foreign to play against a person. Of course, now the idea of playing these board games against a computer on 'video screens' is only normal! Children are good at accepting details they don't fully understand and even so enjoying a story, and even if they don't understand the references to this they would hopefully take information technology as interesting quirks about the engineering of the hereafter.
...more
The only other affair I remember is the journey to some other planet took a couple years and each person could choose i book to bring. Equally an accompanying activity we thought of what volume we would bring. I chose the presently-to-be released Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban;
I believe i of my teachers read this to us in school. I couldn't recall the title or much about it so I googled the following: "childrens science fiction book where they travel to another planet with clear trees." Success.The just other thing I remember is the journeying to another planet took a couple years and each person could choose one book to bring. Every bit an accompanying activity we thought of what book nosotros would bring. I chose the soonhoped-for released Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban; which, looking dorsum, is a terrible choice under the circumstances.
...more
As I was reading the book I thought information technology came from the sixties and was surprise information technology came from the eighties. It has the cold war attiude that Earth is doomed. It made me also think of The Piffling Prince which too wasn't my loving cup of tea.
The science of the book too seems to belong more to the sixties than the eighties. For instance it skips over how a group of people coul
Very strange narration. It slips from an unknow starting time person narration to tertiary person. At the finish the strange narration is explained.As I was reading the book I thought it came from the sixties and was surprise it came from the eighties. It has the cold war attiude that World is doomed. Information technology made me as well think of The Little Prince which also wasn't my loving cup of tea.
The science of the book also seems to belong more to the sixties than the eighties. For example it skips over how a group of people could mayhap survive for 4 years in a small spaceship with chickens and rabbits. The aliens they encouter make no scientific sense. A planet of glass?
It not a horrible book just, it is not a corking one either.
...more
Very thought-provoking for kids that age, who might not have ever considered a concept like colonizing a new land or a new world. Esp
My son'southward 3rd grade class read this volume, and I picked information technology up and started reading it. I plant the first affiliate very interesting, so I really went to the library and checked it out so he could take his re-create dorsum to course. Information technology is an interesting little story about a group of people who become to colonize another planet after something devastating has happened on Earth.Very thought-provoking for kids that age, who might not have e'er considered a concept like colonizing a new country or a new world. Especially suburban and city kids who have always had everything they need, and nigh things they want. Kids who take never considered where things actually come from, besides "the shop" that is.
...more
It's only 66 pages long, merely I felt similar I'd read a proper classic of the genre.
Jill Paton Walsh's writing is so bright, rich and immediate - I swear she writes as though the printed word was a vocal.

Equally science fiction, it makes no sense. The destruction of the Earth, the trip to the alien planet, the resources that colonists might be expected to have -- all are either vague, or really puzzling. Simply I don't remember this would bother a child of the right age -- that's a time when wolves can assume the shape of Grandma, and ponies talk and fly, and unhappy princesses tin can plough anything they expect at to ice. And information technology's a well know fact that adults do & say the darndest things -- the wise child just nods and smiles, and goes forth with it. And that'due south another affair that will ingratiate this book to the average 8+ year old-- the children are the smartest people in the book. The adults don't permit for the most basic necessities for the colonization of an alien planet. they organize themselves in a fashion that is almost guaranteed to cause hard feelings and dissent. They say that each person can but bring I BOOK and and then don't coordinate the choices, so that there are six copies of Robinson Caruso and no Shakespeare, or Milton, or Agatha Christie. No real spoiler, just everything good and interesting that happens to the colonists on this alien planet is the upshot of the children's explorations, marvel and bravery. Kids will dear that.
Then this isn't difficult SF, and I'1000 sure it wasn't meant to exist, but more than like a legend about leaving everything behind, adapting to a new life, and encountering strange new phenomena. And, perhaps, learning that your parents aren't quite every bit smart equally they like to think they are.
The simply thing that makes me feel that I should look at least a couple of years to introduce my granddaughter to this book is (view spoiler)[ that Paton Walsh doesn't sidestep the terrible situation that has driven these families to leave home with little more than Robinson Caruso to guide them, and the night consequences of failure. The Earth is dead, and the colonists accept been supplied with Pills that volition requite them (and their children) a merciful release if their crops fail, or the alien planet is likewise viciously uninhabitable. I can just imagine GD request What are those pills for, Grandma?, and I remember she can await some other couple of years to journey to the planet of Shine. (hide spoiler)]
...more than

The Green Book is short and sweet. It doesn't even feel worth quoting, actually, because in the time that y'all could read the quotes, yous could well-nigh read the unabridged volume. That's non a bad thing. The Green Book is a brilliant and meaningful vignette into a scifi world.
(view spoiler)[Ane thing that I was a piffling confused near was why everyone was and then hateful to
I commencement read The Green Book in the 2d course, and it'south nigh exactly equally I remember it. Possibly because there'south non all that much to remember.The Dark-green Book is short and sweet. Information technology doesn't even experience worth quoting, actually, because in the time that you could read the quotes, you could nearly read the unabridged book. That'south not a bad thing. The Green Book is a vivid and meaningful vignette into a scifi world.
(view spoiler)[One thing that I was a trivial dislocated about was why everyone was then mean to Pattie for bringing a journal. Sure, it would probably exist possible to make paper on the new planet, but it might take quite some time for the community to accomplish that point. Shelter, food, and water would plainly have priority over newspaper making, and information technology would take time to develop and manufacture things equally simple equally a wire screen for setting the paper pulp. And then for months or even years at that place would be no manner to record what happened in Shine. Places of involvement found through exploration would have to exist retained in memory only. Methods of agriculture that had been tried already would have to be remembered. Having some kind of written record available just makes sense.
Of course, the big takeaway at the end of the story is that the primeval history of Shine would have been lost to the ages, were information technology non for Pattie'due south periodical. (hide spoiler)]
I enjoyed the book's message that while information technology's important to preserve the past, it'south also incredibly of import to look toward the time to come, every bit my recent entree into prospective psychology confirms. In a community where everyone else was bemoaning the lost history of Earth, Pattie was fix to (literally and figuratively) write the history of Shine. Emphasizing this gap in thought between Pattie and the older members of the customs does brand for good storytelling, hitting the betoken home, and I think information technology's a very important message.
The future, or at least what we perceive the future to exist, has an immense impact on our happiness. We must look for great things ahead of usa.
...more than

This made my babyhood fun and memorable. I dear it. these are the kinds of books you lot won't easily forget because the story is really good and mysterious.
this book made me a sci-fi loving reader!! I love scifi! THUMBS Upwardly!!!
I read this when I was ten. I didn't know what the championship was because the cover was ripped off. But I however found a way to look it up :D.This fabricated my babyhood fun and memorable. I honey it. these are the kinds of books you won't hands forget because the story is actually good and mysterious.
this volume made me a sci-fi loving reader!! I dearest scifi! THUMBS UP!!!
...more than





topics | posts | views | concluding activity | |
---|---|---|---|---|
What'southward the Name o...: SOLVED. The story of colonists who exit Earth, can only have one book. 80s or 90s - kids' chapter volume [due south] | 8 | 743 | January 22, 2022 12:33PM | |
What'south the Name o...: SOLVED. Childrens/ YA Science Fiction chapter volume. Principal characters are making a homestead on another planet (peradventure Mars)? Read around 2006-2009. [southward] | 7 | 31 | Nov 04, 2021 06:51AM | |
What's the Name o...: SOLVED. YA Sci-Fi genre; Earth is dead and this girl and some people have to go to a new planet to live; its difficult to grow things there and i vaguely think something about corn; read it around 2012-2015. [s] | three | 603 | April 24, 2021 02:41PM | |
What's the Name o...: SOLVED. YA Sci-Fi novel. Girl built-in in the future on spaceship, lives on pretty planet with fields, doesn't remember much of Globe. Read in 2009. [southward] | 5 | 43 | Jan 31, 2021 07:08PM | |
What's the Proper name o...: Little kid lands on planet with survivors and they nearly starve crusade the plants grow like crystals. [s] | 9 | 53 | May 01, 2013 10:35PM | |
What's the Proper noun o...: wheat fields of glass [southward] | half-dozen | twoscore | Jan 27, 2013 07:58PM | |
What's the Name o...: YA Science Fiction book about girl moving with family to new planet to escape the uninhabitable earth [due south] | 3 | 148 | Jun 15, 2012 08:59AM |
Jill Paton Walsh has won the Volume Globe Festival Award, 1970, for Fireweed; the Whitbread Prize, 1974 (for a Children's novel) for The Emperor's Winding Sheet; The
Jill Paton Walsh was born Gillian Bliss in London on April 29th, 1937. She was educated at St. Michael'southward Convent, North Finchley, and at St. Anne's College, Oxford. From 1959 to 1962 she taught English language at Enfield Girls' Grammer School.Jill Paton Walsh has won the Book World Festival Award, 1970, for Fireweed; the Whitbread Prize, 1974 (for a Children's novel) for The Emperor'south Winding Sheet; The Boston Earth-Horn Book Laurels 1976 for Unleaving; The Universe Prize, 1984 for A Packet of Patterns; and the Smarties G Prix, 1984, for Gaffer Samson's Luck.
Series:
* Imogen Quy
* Lord Peter Wimsey and Harriet Vane
Related Manufactures

Welcome back. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account.

The Green Book Jill Paton Walsh Read Free
Source: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/252262.The_Green_Book
0 Response to "The Green Book Jill Paton Walsh Read Free"
Post a Comment